Lies, Half-Truths And Talking Points, Part III

More about the Jay Inslee health care townhall meeting.

The most enthusiastically received question of the afternoon, “…in this atmosphere, in this climate of financial crisis with trillions of dollars of deficit we, we have, what is our confidence in the government estimates of both savings and spending?  They’ve been wrong over and over and over and over [inaudible due to applause and cheers].”

What’s this? An opportunity to get in a dig at George W. Bush? As I said in my previous post, Inslee is not ashamed to pander to his base.

“You know, uh, you are, you are totally, totally accurate.  Uh, I, for one, who has been concerned about the federal deficit for a long time, and I can tell you that you are totally accurate that the U.S. government has been wrong on its predictions of costs.  When Paul Wolfowitz and George Bush told us [inaudible]…”

I’m assuming he went on to say something about the cost estimates for the Iraq war. It was hard to hear the specifics over the (roughly equal) cheers and jeers from the crowd. Frankly, I’m not sure why the there was any booing; while I was annoyed that Inslee felt the need to bring up Bush, he was also making the point rather nicely: the government does indeed have a dismal track record when it comes to cost projections.

When the noise died down, he continued:

“Those who are trying to shout me down on this subject, I want you to know, I’m not in-, intimidated by your shouting.”

I almost felt sorry for Inslee at this point. I’m sure he was hoping someone would show up packing a 54 caliber automatic or, at the very least, a really big finger so he’d have an exciting townhall story or two to share around the water cooler. Instead, he’s reduced to claiming that he’s not intimidated by shouting. How manly.

If you were interested in Inslee’s answer to the question that was asked, why the government should be trusted to estimate the cost of this program – sorry, he never answered it. How could he? There is no logical reason we should expect government cost projections to be even in the ballpark. Leaving aside the fact that we’re talking about a group of individuals who can’t even make a guess as to how many people will take advantage of rather generous rebates on new cars, this is an enormous program that’s being proposed. I’m not sure anyone could make accurate projections.

So in place of a real answer, Inslee gave a rambling discourse on the deficit and, well, just how great Jay Inslee really is; how concerned he is about the deficit; how much stuff he knows that you don’t know: how bold he was to defy his own party and vote against TARP (okay, I’ll give him that one…but he did vote for ARRA). It was really quite self-serving, even for a politician.

3 Comments

Filed under Washington

3 responses to “Lies, Half-Truths And Talking Points, Part III

  1. Mike

    I was there and disappointed. That was perhaps the most important question (maybe rivaled by the “would you use this insurance plan?”), and was very disappointed with his dodge. That’s a lack of respect for the voters.

    • paulag1955

      Oh, I agree, Inslee has absolutely no respect for the voters. As I was writing this post today, I was wishing there was some kind of typographic convention that denoted sneering that I could have used for the Inslee quote.

  2. Mike

    … yet the voters continue to elect him by wide margins.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s